All products featured on Self are independently selected by our editors.
However, we may receive compensation from retailers and/or from purchases of products through these links.
If eyes are the windows to the soul, then the best eye makeup products are their well-dressed treatments.
Andy Jackson. Wardrobe styling by Herin Choi. Hair by Junya Nakashima. Makeup by Akiko Owada. Earrings courtesy of Albright Fashion House.
Read the rest of our dermatologist board criteriahere.
Reviews have been edited and condensed for clarity and length.
See full ingredients listhere.
Since this mascaras formula contains jojoba oil, its also a great option for combination skin types.
One tester said:This is a really good mascarait goes on easily with no clumps.
Its waterproof formula dries fairly quickly and passes my smudge test.
Plus, it wasnt difficult to remove at the end of the day.
See full ingredients listhere.
One tester said:Every powder in this palette is absolutely stunning.
The one beautiful opalescent shade (Astral Pink Moon) is unlike any eye shadow Ive ever seen before.
I generally shy away from pink-toned eye shadows, but these shades are so vibrant.
See full ingredients listhere.
Just so you know:This liner contains citric acid, which may be irritating tosensitive skinand eyes.
I really like its built-in grip that makes it super comfortable to hold.
The liners tip is extremely pointy, making for precise tool.
It’s deeply pigmented and goes on smoothly, which makes drawing wings abreeze.
And once it dries, this liner does not budge.
I could rub my eyes and this liner would still stay in place perfectly.
See complete product detailshere.
One tester said:Excellent, high-end lashes and tool.
Its packaging is practically perfect!
After I apply the falsies, my lashes look thicker and more enhanced without being too dramatic.
See full ingredients listhere.
Checking off all of those boxes is no easy feat!
Plus, I love the addition of aloe vera in the pencil formula, as I have sensitive eyes.
This pencil will definitely be a staple in my makeup bag.
See full ingredients listhere.
One tester said:The first thing I noticed about this brow gel was the brush.
It’ll likely be a new beauty staple for me.
See full ingredients listhere.
One tester said:The gold packaging on this pencil is pretty extra, but I love it.
It also has a spoolie on one end to create a natural-looking finish.
See complete product detailshere.
One tester said:The thing I really love most about this brow brush is the feel of it.
It’s thick and pretty sturdynot flimsy like a lot of brow brushes I’ve used before.
This one actually feels like a legit tool.
The squeeze tube shadows are available in eight earthy shades that our testers find versatile and easy to use.
See full ingredients listhere.
This is a great product with a lovely texture and, as I noted, some versatility.
See full ingredients listhere.
One tester said:I absolutely love this product.
Its texture is easy to blend, and still looks great when I apply it in a rush.
The shadow really lasts all day, but is also extremely easy to wash off.
See full ingredients listhere.
With just one or two swipes youll notice falsies-level length, volume, and thickness.
See full ingredients listhere.
One tester said:I wish this mascara came into my life soonerIlovethis product.
Its formula is also ophthalmologist tested, making it ideal for sensitive eyes.
See full ingredients listhere.
Its formula goes on easily and doesnt clump, which I really appreciate.
This drugstore mascara is definitely worth buying.
