All products featured on Self are independently selected by our editors.
However, we may receive compensation from retailers and/or from purchases of products through these links.
It might leave your dinner guests wondering, Whatwasthat stuff you added at the end?
Chelsea Kyle. Prop styling by Amy Elise Wilson at Laird and Good Company.
It upgrades texture, body, and above all, flavor when you need it most.
Georgia Grinders Original Almond Butter
Georgia Grinders
Original Almond Butter (12 oz.)
From texture to taste, it elevates oatmeal, smoothies, or a bite of dark chocolate.
One tester said:Almond butter can be kinda meh by nature, but I really like this one!
The fact that the almonds are roasted adds nice depth.
There also wasnt much oil separation, so it was pretty easy to stir.
Its pricey, but Id buy it myself because it checks all my boxes.
but with more earthiness thanks to its star ingredient, tahini.
The texture is also greatso creamy and pretty thick, but still works well for drizzling.
One tester said:This is so beautifully packaged, I keep it out on my counter!
While not incredibly spicy, its flavorful and a great addition to any Italian dish for an extra kick.
Whether whisked into dressings or shaken over spaghetti, itll add a little brightness where you need it.
One tester said:We were really impressed by this one!
One tester said:These knocked.
This is what Ina means when she says GOOD olive oil.
Kosterina Original Extra-Virgin Olive Oil
Kosterina
Original Extra Virgin Olive Oil (500 ml.)
From morning eggs to an evening bowl of ice cream, it enhances a wide variety of meals.
Testers loved the elegant bottle design too.
It tastes absolutely amazing and reminds me of some of the best oils I had back in Italy.
Where the former is flavorfuleven spicythe latter is subtler and more utilitarian.
I used Drizzle to top a fancy toast and it was smooth and delicious.
Thrive Market Organic Classic Marinara Sauce
Organic Classic Marinara Sauce (25 oz.)
Why we love it:This marinara sauce is an excellent reminder that simple doesnt have to mean boring.
One tester said:I loved the organic ingredients, and the taste did not disappoint.
The packaging is super inviting and easy to open.
(Its Homemade Marinara Sauce won aPantry Award last year).
One tester said:This was super good!
It did the job for the cost!
Yo Mamas Original Marinara Sauce
Yo Mamas
Original Marinara (12.5 oz.)
Enjoy it as-is, or stir in red pepper flakes for additional heat, as one tester recommends.
This was lovely in that respect; I wouldnt know anything was missing.
), and a really distinct, fab herbiness.
Gluten-free, vegan
PF Changs Sauces
P.F.
Chang’s
Home Menu Sauce (14 oz.)
They blend nicely with bowls of veggies, proteins, and starches.
One tester noted how well the sauce clung to their food, which, you know, isthegood sign.
I would definitely reach for this again, as well as use it to marinate meat.
Blank Slate Kitchen Zhug
Blank Slate Kitchen
Zhug (6 fl.
(You dont need a lot to go a long way, another tester advised.)
One tester said:Holy heaven, is this delicious!
One tester said:Whew!
These pack a punch but theyre GOOD.
Im Thai with an inherent flair for heat and these are delicious!
Its an ideal option to add to meals that need a little sauce or more flavor.
Why we love it:Ketchup purists, this ones for you.
Instead, youll get their thickest, most vibrant take on the condiment to date.
It had a nice, tomatoey flavor and wasnt too sweet.
Kosher
Heinz Spicy Ketchup
HEINZ
Jalapeno Tomato Ketchup Blended With Jalapeno (14 oz.)
One tester said:We shockingly love this?!
Why we love it:If youre unfamiliar with banana ketchup, welcome.
It goes well with a lot of food, and it is rather tasty!
Big Fork Gangster Sauce
Big Fork
Gangster Sauce (8 oz.)
The resulting blend is rich, potent, and easy to eat on anything in need of some dazzle.
Stellar, no notes.
Hellmanns Real Mayonnaise
Hellmanns Mayonnaise
Real Mayonnaise (20 fl.
Why we love it:This refreshingly light vinegar pairs well with foods across the flavor spectrum.
Testers raved about it, noting how it elevated and added a mild bite to their dinners and desserts.
ice cream???
), but this stuff is liquid gold.
I used it to cook potato wedges and have been drizzling it over salads, and its absolutely delicious.
Its nice and light, and the sweetness interacts wonderfully with the classic vinegar tang.
Plus, a little goes a long way.
Its flavor is balanced and well-rounded, and our tester already has it in mind for future housewarming gifts.
I love this for quick little side salads, or along with some bread and olive oil.
